What is art? Thatâs something nobody can agree on.
 |
| Great Danes and Doberman Pinschers talk about what they plan to wear to my daughter’s wedding. |
Last night I assembled an august panel of artists to help me with a project. Barb is a printmaker with an art degree from University of Maine. Sandy is a gallerist with degrees from Pratt and Hunter College. Together, we dressed 42 dogs in wedding finery. (As so often happens in sweatshops, I âforgotâ to pay them.)
âIs this art?â I asked two other artist friends.
âItâs like asking if a soy product in the shape of a chicken leg is food,â said one. âTechnically, yes, but itâs bad food.â
âI guess the individual sculptures are art,â hedged the other, who then raised the question of whether theyâre craft or even, just possibly, crap.
 |
| Two coats of silver and three of glitter… good taste, by the way, is repressive at times. |
âArtistryâ is easier to define than art itself. That means the skill necessary to produce a work of the imagination. But what defines the product of the imagination as art rather than engineering or craft?
Ars longa, vita brevis, wrote Hippocrates. He probably meant that it takes a long time to acquire and perfect artistry, but that the practitioner has only a short lifespan in which to practice. We repeat it, instead, to mean, âart lasts forever, but life is short.â That is, of course, a modern conceit. The ancients understood that âwhat is seen is temporary, but what is unseen is eternal.â (2 Cor. 4:18)
 |
| Barb felt that a DeWalt glue gun was not the tool for the job. |
Platosaid that art is always a copy of a copy, an imitation of reality. This leads us from the truth and to illusion, making art inherently dangerous. (Rich words from a philosopher!) Elsewhere, he hinted that the artist, by divine inspiration, makes a better copy of truth than may be found in everyday experience. This makes artists prophets of sorts.
A lot of artists have had a go at defining art. Many are coy, like Marc Chagall, who said that âArt is the unceasing effort to compete with the beauty of flowersâand never succeeding.â
Even in non-traditional art, imitation is a recurring theme. âArt is either a plagiarist or a revolutionary,â said Paul Gauguin. What makes an Andy Warhol painting of soup cans different from the soup cans themselves? Intent and meaning. Pablo Picasso said that art is a lie that makes us see the truth.
In some way, art is the taking of an idea and making it manifest. Otherwise, itâs just a fleeting thought.
 |
| Sandy and I sewed their garments, Barb dressed them. |
People frequently debate the line between art and craft. Art is useless in practical terms; it exists solely to drive emotion and thought. Fine craft does that and more. It must serve a practical purpose along with being beautiful. Since I didnât drill their noses out to hold flowers, my party dogs fall on the side of art.
Neither fine art nor fine craft are mass-produced, however. That is manufacturing. Those brass birds from Home Goods, as inscrutable as their meaning and purpose might be, qualify as neither art nor craft.
âThe craftsman knows what he wants to make before he makes it. The making of a work of art⌠is a strange and risky business in which the maker never knows quite what he is making until he makes it, wrote R.G. Collingwood in The Principles of Art. That sounds very nice, until I think of dye-master Jane Bartlett throwing pots of color into the snow to see what shows up. Her textiles end up as clothing, but her process is wildly unpredictable.
